Smeargle (WBSP 32). Charmander (TR 50). counter doens't leave after evolution
------------------Begin Game Log------------------
The game is about to start
Type: QuickPlay
Format: Base–Neo
Battle begins between Ritchieman and Leo_Nezeiklus_IX!
Spectation disabled.
Coin flip [Opening Flip]: TAILS
Leo_Nezeiklus_IX will start
Game setup complete
Between turns
Turn 1 begins
Leo_Nezeiklus_IX drew 1 card
[Leo_Nezeiklus_IX]: gl hf
Leo_Nezeiklus_IX played Bill.
Leo_Nezeiklus_IX drew 2 cards
Attached a [R] Energy to Charmander
DEBUG: Charmander's Current_Energy_Cards: [[R] Energy]
Put Cleffa onto bench.
Charmander used Fire Tail
Oddish is weak to FIRE
Charmander did 40 damage to Oddish
Between turns
Turn 2 begins
Ritchieman drew 1 card
Put Erika's Bellsprout onto bench.
Put Smeargle onto bench.
Ritchieman played Computer Search.
Ritchieman has shuffled deck.
Ritchieman played Professor Oak.
Ritchieman drew 7 cards
Put Murkrow onto bench.
Ritchieman played Misty's Wrath.
Put 2 cards to Hand
Warp Point (G2 126) was discarded
Pokemon Breeder (BS 76) was discarded
Computer Search (BS 71) was discarded
Professor Oak (BS 88) was discarded
Dark Gloom (TR 36) was discarded
Attached a Recycle Energy (N1 105) to Oddish
DEBUG: Oddish's Current_Energy_Cards: [Recycle Energy (N1 105)]
Put [Recycle Energy (N1 105)] to Hand
Recycle Energy has recycled
Recycle Energy (N1 105) was discarded
Oddish retreated.
Murkrow is now active
Ritchieman played Lass.
Between turns
Turn 3 begins
Leo_Nezeiklus_IX drew 1 card
Put Mareep onto bench.
Attached a [L] Energy to Mareep
DEBUG: Mareep's Current_Energy_Cards: [[L] Energy]
Leo_Nezeiklus_IX played Professor Elm.
Put 4 cards to Deck
Leo_Nezeiklus_IX has shuffled deck.
Leo_Nezeiklus_IX drew 7 cards
Charmander used Fire Tail
Charmander did 20 damage to Murkrow
Between turns
Turn 4 begins
Ritchieman drew 1 card
Attached a Recycle Energy (N1 105) to Smeargle
DEBUG: Smeargle's Current_Energy_Cards: [Recycle Energy (N1 105)]
Ritchieman played Computer Search.
Ritchieman has shuffled deck.
Put Cleffa onto bench.
Murkrow retreated.
Smeargle is now active
Smeargle used Paint
Coin flip [Paint]: HEADS
Charmander is now PSYCHIC type.
Between turns
Turn 5 begins
Leo_Nezeiklus_IX drew 1 card
Leo_Nezeiklus_IX played Gust Of Wind.
Oddish is now active
Attached a Double Colorless Energy (BS 96) to Mareep
DEBUG: Mareep's Current_Energy_Cards: [[L] Energy, Double Colorless Energy (BS 96)]
Leo_Nezeiklus_IX played Professor Elm.
Put 5 cards to Deck
Leo_Nezeiklus_IX has shuffled deck.
Leo_Nezeiklus_IX drew 7 cards
Charmander used Fire Tail
Charmander did 20 damage to Oddish
Oddish was knocked out
Leo_Nezeiklus_IX took one prize card.
Smeargle is now active
Between turns
Turn 6 begins
Ritchieman drew 1 card
Put [Recycle Energy (N1 105)] to Hand
Recycle Energy has recycled
Recycle Energy (N1 105) was discarded
Smeargle retreated.
Cleffa is now active
Attached a Recycle Energy (N1 105) to Cleffa
DEBUG: Cleffa's Current_Energy_Cards: [Recycle Energy (N1 105)]
Cleffa used Eeeeeeek
Put 4 cards to Deck
Ritchieman has shuffled deck.
Ritchieman drew 7 cards
Between turns
Turn 7 begins
Leo_Nezeiklus_IX drew 1 card
[R] Energy was discarded
Charmander retreated.
Cleffa is now active
Put Charmander onto bench.
Attached a [R] Energy to Cleffa
DEBUG: Cleffa's Current_Energy_Cards: [[R] Energy]
Put Charmander onto bench.
Gold Berry (N1 93) is attached to Mareep
Coin flip [Baby Rule]: TAILS
Baby Rule ends turn without attacking
Between turns
Turn 8 begins
Ritchieman drew 1 card
Healing Field is now in play.
Cleffa retreated.
Murkrow is now active
Coin flip [Healing Field]: HEADS
Murkrow was restored to full health.
Murkrow retreated.
Cleffa is now active
Attached a Recycle Energy (N1 105) to Smeargle
DEBUG: Smeargle's Current_Energy_Cards: [Recycle Energy (N1 105)]
Coin flip [Baby Rule]: HEADS
Cleffa used Eeeeeeek
Put 6 cards to Deck
Ritchieman has shuffled deck.
Ritchieman drew 7 cards
Between turns
Turn 9 begins
Leo_Nezeiklus_IX drew 1 card
Attached a [R] Energy to Charmander
DEBUG: Charmander's Current_Energy_Cards: [[R] Energy]
Healing Field (N3 61) will be discarded as Rocket's Hideout (N3 63) is played.
Healing Field (N3 61) was discarded
Rocket's Hideout is now in play.
Coin flip [Baby Rule]: TAILS
Baby Rule ends turn without attacking
Between turns
Turn 10 begins
Ritchieman drew 1 card
Ritchieman played Pokemon Trader.
Pokemon Trader trades a [Smeargle (WBSP 32)] in hand for a [Erika's Victreebel (G1 26)] from deck!
Put [Smeargle (WBSP 32)] to Deck
Put [Erika's Victreebel (G1 26)] to Hand
Ritchieman has shuffled deck.
Ritchieman played Pokemon Breeder.
Erika's Bellsprout evolved into Erika's Victreebel
Ritchieman played Warp Point.
Mareep is now active
Murkrow is now active
Erika's Victreebel has used Fragrance Trap
Coin flip [Fragrance Trap]: HEADS
Charmander is now active
Attached a Darkness Energy (N1 104) to Murkrow
DEBUG: Murkrow's Current_Energy_Cards: [Darkness Energy (N1 104)]
Murkrow retreated.
Cleffa is now active
Cleffa used Eeeeeeek
Put 3 cards to Deck
Ritchieman has shuffled deck.
Ritchieman drew 7 cards
Between turns
Turn 11 begins
Leo_Nezeiklus_IX drew 1 card
Attached a [L] Energy to Charmander
DEBUG: Charmander's Current_Energy_Cards: [[L] Energy]
[L] Energy was discarded
Charmander retreated.
Cleffa is now active
Coin flip [Baby Rule]: HEADS
Cleffa used Eeeeeeek
Put 4 cards to Deck
Leo_Nezeiklus_IX has shuffled deck.
Leo_Nezeiklus_IX drew 7 cards
Between turns
Turn 12 begins
Ritchieman drew 1 card
Erika's Victreebel has used Fragrance Trap
Coin flip [Fragrance Trap]: HEADS
Charmander is now active
Ritchieman played Lass.
Put [Switch (BS 95), Pokemon Breeder (BS 76), Pokemon Breeder (BS 76)] to Deck
Leo_Nezeiklus_IX has shuffled deck.
Put [Lass (BS 75)] to Deck
Ritchieman has shuffled deck.
Cleffa used Eeeeeeek
Put 6 cards to Deck
Ritchieman has shuffled deck.
Ritchieman drew 7 cards
Between turns
Turn 13 begins
Leo_Nezeiklus_IX drew 1 card
Attached a [R] Energy to Charmander
DEBUG: Charmander's Current_Energy_Cards: [[R] Energy]
Coin flip [Baby Rule]: TAILS
Baby Rule ends turn without attacking
Between turns
Turn 14 begins
Ritchieman drew 1 card
Ritchieman played Pokemon Trader.
Pokemon Trader trades a [Smeargle (WBSP 32)] in hand for a [Oddish (TR 63)] from deck!
Put [Smeargle (WBSP 32)] to Deck
Put [Oddish (TR 63)] to Hand
Ritchieman has shuffled deck.
Put Oddish onto bench.
Erika's Victreebel has used Fragrance Trap
Coin flip [Fragrance Trap]: TAILS
Cleffa used Eeeeeeek
Put 6 cards to Deck
Ritchieman has shuffled deck.
Ritchieman drew 7 cards
Between turns
Turn 15 begins
Leo_Nezeiklus_IX drew 1 card
Charmander evolved into Dark Charmeleon
Attached a Darkness Energy (N1 104) to Dark Charmeleon
DEBUG: Dark Charmeleon's Current_Energy_Cards: [[R] Energy, Darkness Energy (N1 104)]
Coin flip [Baby Rule]: HEADS
Dark Charmeleon used Tail Slap
Darkness Energy +10
Dark Charmeleon did 30 damage to Cleffa
Cleffa was knocked out
Put [Recycle Energy (N1 105)] to Hand
Recycle Energy has recycled
Leo_Nezeiklus_IX took one prize card.
Murkrow is now active
Between turns
Turn 16 begins
Ritchieman drew 1 card
Ritchieman played Misty's Wrath.
Put 2 cards to Hand
Cleffa (N1 20) was discarded
Recycle Energy (N1 105) was discarded
Erika's Weepinbell (G1 49) was discarded
Smeargle (WBSP 32) was discarded
Pokemon Trader (BS 77) was discarded
Ritchieman played Computer Search.
Ritchieman has shuffled deck.
Ritchieman played Pokemon Breeder.
Oddish evolved into Dark Vileplume
Attached a Recycle Energy (N1 105) to Murkrow
DEBUG: Murkrow's Current_Energy_Cards: [Recycle Energy (N1 105), Darkness Energy (N1 104)]
Murkrow used Mean Look
Between turns
Turn 17 begins
Leo_Nezeiklus_IX drew 1 card
Dark Charmeleon used Tail Slap
Murkrow resists PSYCHIC
Dark Charmeleon did 0 damage to Murkrow
Between turns
Turn 18 begins
Ritchieman drew 1 card
Put Cleffa onto bench.
Murkrow used Feint Attack
Murkrow did 20 damage to Charmander
Between turns
Turn 19 begins
Leo_Nezeiklus_IX drew 1 card
Attached a Darkness Energy (N1 104) to Dark Charmeleon
DEBUG: Dark Charmeleon's Current_Energy_Cards: [[R] Energy, Darkness Energy (N1 104), Darkness Energy (N1 104)]
Dark Charmeleon used Tail Slap
Murkrow resists PSYCHIC
Dark Charmeleon did 0 damage to Murkrow
Between turns
Turn 20 begins
Ritchieman drew 1 card
Murkrow used Feint Attack
Murkrow did 20 damage to Charmander
Charmander was knocked out
Ritchieman took one prize card.
Between turns
Turn 21 begins
Leo_Nezeiklus_IX drew 1 card
Dark Charmeleon used Tail Slap
Murkrow resists PSYCHIC
Dark Charmeleon did 0 damage to Murkrow
Between turns
Turn 22 begins
Ritchieman drew 1 card
Murkrow used Feint Attack
Murkrow did 20 damage to Charmander
Between turns
Turn 23 begins
Leo_Nezeiklus_IX drew 1 card
Between turns
Turn 24 begins
Ritchieman drew 1 card
Murkrow used Feint Attack
Murkrow did 20 damage to Charmander
Charmander was knocked out
Ritchieman took one prize card.
Between turns
Turn 25 begins
Leo_Nezeiklus_IX drew 1 card
Between turns
Turn 26 begins
Ritchieman drew 1 card
Murkrow used Feint Attack
Murkrow did 20 damage to Cleffa
Between turns
Turn 27 begins
Leo_Nezeiklus_IX drew 1 card
Between turns
Turn 28 begins
Ritchieman drew 1 card
Murkrow retreated.
Smeargle is now active
Put [Recycle Energy (N1 105)] to Hand
Recycle Energy has recycled
Recycle Energy (N1 105) was discarded
Smeargle retreated.
Cleffa is now active
Attached a Recycle Energy (N1 105) to Cleffa
DEBUG: Cleffa's Current_Energy_Cards: [Recycle Energy (N1 105)]
Cleffa used Eeeeeeek
Put 12 cards to Deck
Ritchieman has shuffled deck.
Ritchieman drew 7 cards
Between turns
Turn 29 begins
Leo_Nezeiklus_IX drew 1 card
Coin flip [Baby Rule]: HEADS
Dark Charmeleon used Tail Slap
Darkness Energy +10
Darkness Energy +10
Dark Charmeleon did 40 damage to Cleffa
Cleffa was knocked out
Put [Recycle Energy (N1 105)] to Hand
Recycle Energy has recycled
Leo_Nezeiklus_IX took one prize card.
Murkrow is now active
Between turns
Turn 30 begins
Ritchieman drew 1 card
Murkrow used Mean Look
Between turns
Turn 31 begins
Leo_Nezeiklus_IX drew 1 card
Dark Charmeleon used Tail Slap
Murkrow resists PSYCHIC
Dark Charmeleon did 0 damage to Murkrow
Between turns
Turn 32 begins
Ritchieman drew 1 card
Murkrow used Feint Attack
Murkrow did 20 damage to Cleffa
Cleffa was knocked out
Ritchieman took one prize card.
Between turns
Turn 33 begins
Leo_Nezeiklus_IX drew 1 card
Between turns
Turn 34 begins
Ritchieman drew 1 card
Murkrow used Feint Attack
Murkrow did 20 damage to Mareep
Between turns
Turn 35 begins
Leo_Nezeiklus_IX drew 1 card
Between turns
Turn 36 begins
Ritchieman drew 1 card
Erika's Victreebel has used Fragrance Trap
Coin flip [Fragrance Trap]: TAILS
Murkrow used Feint Attack
Murkrow did 20 damage to Mareep
Between turns
Gold berry activates
Mareep was restored to full health.
Gold Berry (N1 93) was discarded
Turn 37 begins
Leo_Nezeiklus_IX drew 1 card
Between turns
Turn 38 begins
Ritchieman drew 1 card
Put Cleffa onto bench.
Attached a Recycle Energy (N1 105) to Cleffa
DEBUG: Cleffa's Current_Energy_Cards: [Recycle Energy (N1 105)]
Murkrow retreated.
Cleffa is now active
Cleffa used Eeeeeeek
Put 12 cards to Deck
Ritchieman has shuffled deck.
Ritchieman drew 7 cards
Between turns
Turn 39 begins
Leo_Nezeiklus_IX drew 1 card
Put Rocket's Zapdos onto bench.
Attached a [L] Energy to Rocket's Zapdos
DEBUG: Rocket's Zapdos's Current_Energy_Cards: [[L] Energy]
Darkness Energy (N1 104) was discarded
[R] Energy was discarded
Dark Charmeleon retreated.
Rocket's Zapdos is now active
Coin flip [Baby Rule]: HEADS
Rocket's Zapdos used Plasma
Attached a [L] Energy to Rocket's Zapdos
DEBUG: Rocket's Zapdos's Current_Energy_Cards: [[L] Energy, [L] Energy]
Rocket's Zapdos did 20 damage to Cleffa
Between turns
Turn 40 begins
Ritchieman drew 1 card
Erika's Victreebel has used Fragrance Trap
Coin flip [Fragrance Trap]: HEADS
Dark Charmeleon is now active
Cleffa retreated.
Murkrow is now active
Murkrow used Mean Look
Between turns
Turn 41 begins
Leo_Nezeiklus_IX drew 1 card
Attached a [L] Energy to Dark Charmeleon
DEBUG: Dark Charmeleon's Current_Energy_Cards: [[L] Energy, Darkness Energy (N1 104)]
Dark Charmeleon used Tail Slap
Murkrow resists PSYCHIC
Dark Charmeleon did 0 damage to Murkrow
Between turns
Turn 42 begins
Ritchieman drew 1 card
Murkrow used Feint Attack
Murkrow did 20 damage to Mareep
Between turns
Turn 43 begins
Leo_Nezeiklus_IX drew 1 card
Attached a Darkness Energy (N1 104) to Dark Charmeleon
DEBUG: Dark Charmeleon's Current_Energy_Cards: [[L] Energy, Darkness Energy (N1 104), Darkness Energy (N1 104)]
Between turns
Turn 44 begins
Ritchieman drew 1 card
Murkrow used Feint Attack
Murkrow did 20 damage to Mareep
Between turns
Turn 45 begins
Leo_Nezeiklus_IX drew 1 card
Attached a Double Colorless Energy (BS 96) to Dark Charmeleon
DEBUG: Dark Charmeleon's Current_Energy_Cards: [[L] Energy, Double Colorless Energy (BS 96), Darkness Energy (N1 104), Darkness Energy (N1 104)]
Between turns
Turn 46 begins
Ritchieman drew 1 card
Murkrow used Feint Attack
Murkrow did 20 damage to Mareep
Mareep was knocked out
Ritchieman took one prize card.
Between turns
Turn 47 begins
Leo_Nezeiklus_IX drew 1 card
Attached a Double Colorless Energy (BS 96) to Rocket's Zapdos
DEBUG: Rocket's Zapdos's Current_Energy_Cards: [[L] Energy, [L] Energy, Double Colorless Energy (BS 96)]
Between turns
Turn 48 begins
Ritchieman drew 1 card
Murkrow retreated.
Cleffa is now active
Cleffa used Eeeeeeek
Put 13 cards to Deck
Ritchieman has shuffled deck.
Ritchieman drew 7 cards
Between turns
Turn 49 begins
Leo_Nezeiklus_IX drew 1 card
Double Colorless Energy (BS 96) was discarded
Dark Charmeleon retreated.
Rocket's Zapdos is now active
Attached a [R] Energy to Dark Charmeleon
DEBUG: Dark Charmeleon's Current_Energy_Cards: [[R] Energy, [L] Energy, Darkness Energy (N1 104), Darkness Energy (N1 104)]
Coin flip [Baby Rule]: TAILS
Baby Rule ends turn without attacking
Between turns
Turn 50 begins
Ritchieman drew 1 card
Erika's Victreebel has used Fragrance Trap
Coin flip [Fragrance Trap]: HEADS
Dark Charmeleon is now active
Cleffa retreated.
Murkrow is now active
Murkrow used Mean Look
Between turns
Turn 51 begins
Leo_Nezeiklus_IX drew 1 card
Attached a [R] Energy to Dark Charmeleon
DEBUG: Dark Charmeleon's Current_Energy_Cards: [[R] Energy, [R] Energy, [L] Energy, Darkness Energy (N1 104), Darkness Energy (N1 104)]
Dark Charmeleon evolved into Dark Charizard
[Leo_Nezeiklus_IX]: Q. When can you remove the coloring counter from Smeargle? Does the Coloring counter remain on the defending Pokemon if it retreats, evolves, etc. (like "Char" counters)?
[Leo_Nezeiklus_IX]: A. The coloring counter actually isn't on Smeargle, but the only way to remove it from the Pokemon it is attached to is to evolve it or have it leave play. Just like Char counters
Dark Charizard used Continuous Fireball
Coin flip [Continuous Fireball]: TAILS TAILS
Between turns
Turn 52 begins
Ritchieman drew 1 card
[Leo_Nezeiklus_IX]: counters, benching does not remove it. (Mar 22, 2001 WotC Chat, Q13 & Q40)
[Ritchieman]: this web goes under japanese rules, maybe the counter stays in those rulings
Murkrow used Feint Attack
Murkrow did 20 damage to Rocket's Zapdos
Between turns
Turn 53 begins
Leo_Nezeiklus_IX drew 1 card
[Leo_Nezeiklus_IX]: maybe
[Ritchieman]: the WOTC compendium doesn't work here saddly
Dark Charizard used Continuous Fireball
Coin flip [Continuous Fireball]: HEADS HEADS
[R] Energy was discarded
[R] Energy was discarded
Murkrow resists PSYCHIC
Darkness Energy +10
Darkness Energy +10
Dark Charizard did 90 damage to Murkrow
Murkrow was knocked out
Put [Recycle Energy (N1 105)] to Hand
Recycle Energy has recycled
Leo_Nezeiklus_IX took one prize card.
I would like to add the following image about the topic, where you can see that Dark Charizard retained the Psychic type until the end of the battle (instead of recovering the Fire type):