Hello everyone,
Before reporting this issue, I checked the relevant card texts and ruling explanations concerning Gengar & Mimikyu-GX’s Horror House-GX.
Rules checked
Horror House-GX states:
“Your opponent can’t play any cards from their hand during their next turn.”
The relevant ruling explanation clarifies that while this effect is active, an Ability itself is not necessarily prohibited. However, if the Ability requires the player to play a card from their hand, that part of the effect cannot be carried out.
For example, Lunatone’s Ability, Lunar Cycle, allows the player to discard a Basic Fighting Energy card from their hand to draw three cards. Discarding a card as the cost of an Ability is different from playing a card from the hand, so this Ability can still be used.
In contrast, Ditto Prism Star’s Ability, Almighty Evolution, requires the player to put a Stage 1 Pokémon from their hand onto Ditto Prism Star to evolve it. This involves playing a Pokémon from the hand and should therefore be prohibited while the effect of Horror House-GX is active.
Affected cards
-
Gengar & Mimikyu-GX — Horror House-GX
-
Ditto Prism Star — Almighty Evolution
-
Alolan Muk
Description of the issue
During a game on TCG ONE, my opponent was able to evolve Ditto Prism Star into Alolan Muk using Almighty Evolution while the effect of Horror House-GX was still active.
Based on the card texts and the ruling explanation described above, I believe this evolution should not have been allowed.
Expected behavior
TCG ONE should prevent the player from evolving Ditto Prism Star by putting a Stage 1 Pokémon from their hand onto it while the effect of Horror House-GX is active.
Actual behavior
TCG ONE allowed the evolution to occur despite the ongoing restriction.
Unfortunately, the game had already ended, so I was unable to submit an in-game bug report.
Could someone familiar with the official Pokémon TCG rulings verify this interaction? If my understanding is correct, this appears to be a gameplay bug that should be investigated.
References
-
Official Ditto Prism Star card text: https://www.pokemon.com/us/pokemon-tcg/pokemon-cards/series/sm8/154/
-
Explanation of Horror House-GX rulings: https://note.com/rk_pkls/n/nafce96709dd4
Thank you for your time and assistance.